Yore Town
ExplorePodcast overview and latest content
EpisodesBrowse the full episode archive

Podcast

  • Explore
  • Episodes

Recent Episodes

  • Pearl Bryan's Head Was Never Found | The Crime That Haunts Indiana and Kentucky
  • Camp Scott Murders They Could Have Stopped | Yore Town
  • The Night a Pilot Landed a Stolen Plane in Manhattan (He Proved It Twice)
  • Anonymous Letters, Real Consequences | America's Forgotten Terror Campaign
  • The Jamison Family Disappeared Leaving Everything Behind | Oklahoma's Strangest Mystery

Links

  • Apple Podcasts
  • Overcast

About

Yore Town

Yore Town

Yore Town Podcast is a true crime and dark history podcast uncovering real small-town mysteries, forgotten crimes, unexplained events, and buried history from places most people overlook. Each episode delivers deep-dive storytelling into true crime cases, unsolved disappearances, eerie local legends, historical cover-ups, and strange but 100% real stories that actually happened. No clickbait. No internet myths. Just well-researched, fact-checked episodes designed to keep you listening until the very end. From chilling murders and cold cases to strange historical moments and unsettling mysteries, Yore Town Podcast blends true crime podcast tension with immersive narrative storytelling. These are the kinds of stories...

Powered byPodRewind
    Yore Town
    Episode•March 23, 2026•27 min

    The Jamison Family Disappeared Leaving Everything Behind | Oklahoma's Strangest Mystery

    Jamison Family Mystery: A family disappears in Oklahoma, leaving behind $32,000, their phones, and even their dog. The Jamison family disappearance is one of the most bizarre and unsettling true crime cases in modern history. In 2009, the Jamison family vanished after driving into the mountains of rural Oklahoma. Days later, their truck was found abandoned deep in the woods—wallets, IDs, cell phones, and a large sum of cash still inside. There were no signs of struggle. No clear clues. And no explanation for why they would leave everything behind. This true crime story quickly became one of the most debated unsolved mysteries in America. From theories of foul play to mental health struggles, and even claims of paranormal activity, the case continues to raise more questions than answers. What really happened to Bobby, Sherilynn, and their daughter Madyson? In this episode of Yore Town Podcast, we break down the full timeline, analyze the strange evidence, and explore the most compelling theories surrounding the Jamison family disappearance. What You’ll Learn: The full timeline of the Jamison family case What was found inside the abandoned truck The eerie surveillance footage before they vanished Key evidence that doesn’t add up The most popular theories (and why none fully fit) What investigators believe may have happened Chapters: 00:00 - Introduction to the mysterious case of the Jamison family 00:33 - Setting the scene: the quiet town in Oklahoma 01:02 - The hosts discuss recent weather and updates on their podcast 02:26 - Introduction of the new YouTube channel and potential content ideas 03:54 - Highlighting the local businesses and products, including Livbearded 04:56 - The importance of community and local brands 05:53 - Remembering Chuck Norris and the world’s fascination with legends 06:29 - Overview of the Jamison family background and initial observations 06:58 - How to pronounce Ufala, Oklahoma 07:17 - The seemingly peaceful town with underlying tensions 08:14 - Bobby’s past accident and family struggles 09:09 - Domestic issues and unsettling household reports 09:38 - Interview with local neighbor "Luther" about the town’s vibe 10:13 - The family's last known movements and mysterious footage 11:27 - The police find the abandoned truck and equipped clues 12:25 - Family’s alleged haunted house and spiritual distress 12:54 - Debating mental health versus supernatural causes 13:43 - The family’s sudden departure toward the mountains 14:13 - Eerie footage of the family packing the truck in a trance-like state 15:39 - The abandoned truck’s contents and their significance 16:28 - The dog Maisie left starving in the vehicle, adding to the mystery 17:40 - No signs of struggle, no footprints, no clues – a real cold case 18:29 - Theories of alien abduction and paranormal involvement 19:02 - The discovery of human remains in 2013, less than 3 miles away 19:59 - Decomposition and unresolved cause of death 20:33 - The possibility of supernatural or extraterrestrial explanations 21:02 - Common hypotheses: murder-suicide, getting lost, drug involvement 22:41 - The difficulty in reconciling the evidence 23:41 - Exploring the hypothesis of drug-related involvement and mental health 25:10 - The influence of perceived paranormal activity 26:15 - Conversation with "Luther" about the case's unresolved mysteries 27:49 - Final theories: mental health crises, paranormal possession, and criminal activity 29:00 - Reflecting on what really happened to the Jamison family 29:32 - Audience engagement: inviting theories and comments 30:02 - Closing remarks and upcoming episodes If you enjoy deep dives into true crime, unsolved mysteries, and small town stories, make sure to subscribe to Yore Town Podcast for more episodes just like this. Hit subscribe, drop your theory in the comments, and let’s figure this out together. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com (https://pcm.adswizz.com) for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

    Apple PodcastsOvercast

    Transcript

    0:00

    Insurance isn't one size fits all. That's why drivers have enjoyed progressive's name your price tool for years. Now, with the name your price tool, you tell them what you want to pay, and they'll show you options that fit your budget. So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family, they make it easy to see your options. Visit progressive.com find a rate that works for you with the name your price tool. Progressive casualty insurance company and affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law.

    0:30

    Imagine packing up your entire life, loading your truck and driving right to the mountains. No warnings, no goodbyes, no explanations. Now imagine this a few days later. Police find your truck. Your phones, they're still inside. Your wallets, they're untouched. Your dog, barely alive but still there and sitting in the front seat, $32,000 in cash. But you, you're gone. There's no signs of struggle. There's no trail. There's no answers. Isn't a movie. This isn't a campfire story. This actually happened in a quiet town in Oklahoma. By the end of this episode, you're gonna have to decide for yourself. Did this family run from something or did they walk straight into it? Welcome to the your town podcast. The voice you're hearing. It's me. It's Matt. It's beard loss. Joining me as always, the beautiful dun dun queen Meg.

    1:34

    Hello.

    1:35

    What's up?

    1:37

    Yeah, it's a sunny day today.

    1:41

    Sunny day today for the moment. St. Patrick's Day. You had a snow day. That hasn't happened in a while, has it?

    1:46

    No.

    1:46

    First day of spring. Also another storm that closed all after school activities in the schools. Mother nature, she's not playing very nice. And winter just won't go away where we are.

    1:57

    Feel like it's a typical march, though.

    1:59

    How so?

    2:00

    We always get storms around St. Patrick's Day.

    2:03

    Stupid. Why do we live here? Want somebody to go back and just tally up every time we start an episode of us complaining about the weather and wondering why we live here. Wild. But a lot of things going on, obviously, and hopefully everybody is good here. All you, your townians enjoying this episode. But for some reason, if you're like, hey, I went to go check it out on the beer laws network and it's not there. Well, we decided it was best that the yourtown just has its own YouTube so we resurrected. Is that the right word? We brought back the your town YouTube so you guys can go to YouTube.com yourtown and you're gonna. Well, see me, because we still haven't made that. What was the money? $50,000 or something for Meg to be on camera. But she did tell me that if we do potentially this, like, food review style show, that she wouldn't mind being the camera person and then being on camera once in a while. If you guys would like to see some of that.

    3:03

    I even have a name for it. Should we tell them the name or just let it go?

    3:07

    I'm curious.

    3:09

    Oh, I told you it's going to be called Beard Walks In.

    3:13

    Oh, yeah, I did know that.

    3:14

    Because how many times do we walk into a place, people are like, nice, beard. How long you been growing that? So we'll walk in, get real reactions, and people are like, how long you been growing that? About 10 years. So what's the best thing on the menu? It's organic, little.

    3:29

    And that's what people call you?

    3:31

    Yeah, beard. So beard walks in, and it could be a restaurant, could be a thrift shop, could be a barber shop, could be a tattoo shop. Maybe we go and get you a tattoo and we talk all about it.

    3:42

    Okay.

    3:43

    I don't know. Sky's the limit. And I figure we're on the road. So much traveling. That's kind of how street sign story time started, right? We. We just travel so much. We started seeing some street signs, and we just started going. I wonder the history about that. Did we just make up the history to begin with? Maybe. Allegedly. But now it's all real stuff in real areas, so maybe we'll start doing this. I mean, how? We. We each have a phone to take footage. I got tripods. We got the fancy one. We got everything we need. I got the fancy mics. I think we're ready. There's our first destination. I'll think about it.

    4:18

    I think about it. Yeah.

    4:19

    All right.

    4:20

    Depends on if we're locally traveling at the time fair. You know what I mean?

    4:25

    I do know what you mean. Cool. All right, check out all the friends of the show. We got Live bearded. Go to livebearded.com, get the best beard products. Did you know, Meg, that Live bearded has a 365 guarantee? If you don't like it, they'll make it, Right?

    4:38

    I did not know that.

    4:39

    Nobody else is doing that in the beard game. Do you know any, like, makeup people or whatever, cosmetology stuff that they do that you got 365 days? Some, but not many. Nobody in the beard game is doing it. It's all made in the U.S. when are we going to go with today. Ted Wood, 1880. I'll let you pick.

    5:00

    Okay.

    5:02

    And we're going to be on the go. We got a basketball tournament. We got to be hydrated. What are we going to have?

    5:06

    Scotch juice.

    5:07

    Yeah, we're going to have all the Squatch juice. Go to beardlaws.com squatch juice. Which one's your favorite?

    5:14

    The watermelon.

    5:15

    Sugar? Why those Watermelon?

    5:17

    Yeah.

    5:19

    I think in lemonade's probably your second.

    5:22

    Yeah, I like the lemonade, but the watermelon is my favorite.

    5:24

    I've been digging the pineapple mango in the.

    5:26

    Is it strawberry watermelon?

    5:28

    Strawberry kiwi.

    5:29

    Oh, no.

    5:29

    Straight watermelon. Just the watermelon then straight lemonade, strawberry kiwi and pineapple mango. I could taste it like in the back. Like I need one right now. That's what I'm having. Instead of coffee, I'm gonna go with an energy one. What you think about that?

    5:44

    Go for it.

    5:45

    Two woos and a clap. We do want to throw a shout out to the legend. Rest in peace. Chuck Norris. One of the worst news that we woke up to. Didn't know him personally, but I was telling Meg that there's all these signs when those like death fish wash up on shore that the apocalypse is coming. Or this sign and this earth. What's that?

    6:06

    Meteors.

    6:07

    Meteors are hitting earth. There's all these signs that the apocalypse has come. The world is coming to an end. But for me, when Chuck Norris dies, the world's coming to an end. I mean, for 86 years he protected us. And now we're screwed. We are screwed.

    6:23

    So Meg Cases probably got a pretty strong ghost though.

    6:27

    He might. He might. I don't know. So if this is the last you are town, we do because the world blows up. It's been a heck of a ride, huh? But let's jump into this. You ready? Okay. Let's start off with a family that on the surface looks normal, right? Bobby Jameson, Marilyn Jameson and their six year old daughter Edison. They lived in O. I don't know how to say this one. Eufaula, Oklahoma. E F A, U, L A. How the heck do you say that? Let's ask. Let's ask one of the smartest people in the room right now other than Meg. How do you say E U, F A U, L A Oklahoma. Ufola. Which sounds like you followed by fall. You follow, you fall. Is that what I said? I'm getting so much better at saying words. They lived in Eufaula, Oklahoma. Just like I said. It was A small town, pretty quiet life. The kind of place where not much is supposed to happen, right? What?

    7:32

    Nothing.

    7:33

    What's wrong? Ms. Correct. Ms. Grammarly. Miss.

    7:37

    You went like.

    7:37

    You're like the squiggly line in the word documents.

    7:40

    You went, like, deep south for a moment.

    7:42

    Well, Oklahoma's pretty south.

    7:43

    Okay.

    7:44

    It's near Texas. And I was born in Texas.

    7:47

    Okay, I'm sorry, y'.

    7:48

    All.

    7:49

    Apologies.

    7:50

    So it's the kind of place where not much is supposed to happen. Pretty typical to our episodes, right? But if you look a little closer, things weren't as perfect as they seemed. Bobby had been through a pretty serious car accident. And a couple years before, after the accident changed Meg, he was in a lot of pain. He struggled with memory issues, and eventually he had to go on disability. Cheryl Lynn, she had her own struggles. There are reports of mental health issues, mood swings, and extreme paranoia. Together. Well, we got two people like that. How do you think the relationship was?

    8:28

    Me?

    8:28

    Is that what we're going with Entertaining? Sure, yeah, maybe. It was on an episode of Cops, which it might have been. I was gonna go with volatile, but we'll go with Meg's entertaining air quotes.

    8:39

    Okay.

    8:40

    And this is a reminder. This is a pretty serious case. People did lose their lives, but we put our take on.

    8:46

    On small towns haven't heard any of that part yet.

    8:48

    Potentially lost their lives. Rewind that one.

    8:50

    I feel like my answer was valid.

    8:52

    Police had been called to their home multiple times. Arguments, domestic disturbances. Some might call that entertainment. But there was nothing that screamed, this is going to end in a mystery. But enough to tell you this wasn't a peaceful household.

    9:08

    What kind of town was it, like

    9:10

    just a small town? Just quite.

    9:12

    Why Outskirts? Or was it like in. Like. Like where it's hustling and bustling?

    9:16

    Well, that's a good question.

    9:18

    You know, you get those neighbors out there with their binoculars looking to see what's happening around the neighborhood.

    9:26

    Let's bring in our. We're bringing our correspondent for all of our questions.

    9:30

    Sure.

    9:31

    All right, let's bring them in. We'll bring in Luther. You ever met Luther?

    9:33

    I haven't met Luther ever.

    9:35

    Haven't I have. Gotcha. All right, all right. Let's. Let's bring an old Luther real quick for a quick question. Luther. Hey, we're. We're doing the Yorktown podcast. Hate to bother you, but Meg wants to know you follow Oklahoma. What kind of town is it? Is it like an outskirt town? Is it, you know, a hustling, bustling town? Let's 2009. Ish. What kind of town is it?

    10:00

    So, eufaula, Oklahoma, around 2009, was a small town of about 2, 600 people sitting by Lake Eufaula, which is. Which covers a chunk of the area. Historically, it has roots with the Muskogee Creek Nation and gained traction with the railroad. It's a historic lakeside town, big on recreation, local legends, and small town charm. Back then, the economy leaned on tourism and local services. Definitely some layers you can dig into.

    10:26

    Yeah, we're doing the true crime case with the Jamesons, and, boy, Meg doesn't know anything about it. Don't give anything away, but this is a pretty wild story, isn't it?

    10:37

    Oh, you're diving into a wild one. All right, I want to spill the beans, but let's just say the twists in that story could make a pretzel jealous. Meg's in for a ride.

    10:47

    Sure. Yes. All right, well, thanks for joining us. You can catch Luther on the Triple T podcast sometimes on the Stay out of My Fridge podcast, and he's gonna go have some beans and toast. All right, so, yes, back to your point. It does appear to be a down where you're sitting on the porch with binoculars watching something like that.

    11:03

    Like cops showing up at someone's house. You. There's a lot of rubbernecking happening.

    11:07

    Rubber. Let's go with that. Let's go with that.

    11:10

    Let's see what's happening. No, nothing exciting happens in towns like

    11:14

    that until it does.

    11:15

    Okay, well, that's where I was going with it.

    11:17

    I like it. I like it. But here's something that takes this story and pushes it into a completely different direction. Sherilyn believed their house was haunted. No, not just that. Like, hey, there's creaking floors at night. Haunted. We're talking, like, full on. Something is in this house with us. Grab the bat. We need to search every closet. Kind of haunted. She claimed the spirits were actually speaking to her, that something dark was inside their home. At one point, she even wrote a letter to her pastor saying they needed some help. They were being tormented. Now, pause right there, Meg, because this. That's where the story starts to split. Is this a family dealing with stress, trauma, and mental health issues, or is something else really happening here? What do you think?

    12:04

    I do believe in ghosts, so I want to believe her, but I don't.

    12:09

    Yeah, I'm leaning towards some mental health side of things or something greeted, you know, paranoia. I have some other things that I'm thinking, but I also know the story, so I'm not gonna. Okay. Because what they do next to most of us doesn't make any sense. We're gonna. October 8, 2009. Bobby and Cheryl Lynn, they load up the truck. Their daughter Madison comes along. Thankfully, they didn't just leave her in the house, but maybe they should have. They just leave. This isn't a normal trip, though. They don't tell anybody where they're going. They don't leave a note. They don't make plans to come back. But what we do know. We don't know everything, obviously, but we do know that they were heading toward the mountains. They believe that they were heading to, like, this remote area near Red Oak, Oklahoma. If you don't know Red Oak, that makes three of us. Now, here's where things get a little extra interesting.

    13:05

    Because before they left, their surveillance footage, the Jameson family captured on camera packing their truck. And if you watch that footage, something just fell off. They're not even talking to each other. They're not moving like they're in a hurry. They're not acting like they're just going on a family trip. They're just moving slowly, quietly, almost like they're in a trance. People who've seen the footage describe it as it's unsettling and just off. And then they just drive away. It's the last time anyone sees them. Now where's your brain at?

    13:43

    Ghosts.

    13:44

    Thinking ghosts. Sticking with the ghosts. Ghosts. Are you listening to that, Jason? Are you listening to that, Zach?

    13:50

    Yes.

    13:51

    You're not either of them. Why would you say yes? I was calling in the ghost hunters.

    13:56

    Yes, that's what I'm taps.

    13:58

    Because I couldn't remember which one was still TAPS and which one is not because of the whole Grant Jason fallout. That kind of broke my heart.

    14:04

    Insurance isn't one size fits all. That's why drivers have enjoyed progressives name your Price tool for years. Now with the name youe Price Tool, you tell them what you want to pay, and they'll show you options that fit your budget. So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family, they make it easy. To see your options, visit progressive.com find a rate that works for you with the name your Price Tool. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state

    14:33

    law Anyways, Hunters, the woods man. Know what they find? A white pickup truck abandoned. The police show up. Know what they found? Well, truck. But the stuff inside didn't make any sense. Both their phones, both their wallets, both their IDs everything that you would take with you if you plan to leave your life behind. But it was all right there. And then there's the dog. Guess what their dog's name was.

    15:00

    Luther.

    15:01

    That'd be cool, but it's amazing. You were really close. One letter off in the Alphabet. Poor Macy was locked inside the truck. Starving, barely alive. I mean, think about that for a second. If they willingly left their dog, right? Why leave it? If they were taken, why leave? What else was in the truck? Cash, in plain sight. It was a bag containing $32,000. It wasn't hidden. It wasn't stolen. It was just there, left behind. And for me, I kind of was thinking, like, what kind of situation would make someone walk away from their child, their money, their home, their truck? Just walk away. Because whatever happened here couldn't have been normal right? Now. What are you thinking?

    15:46

    Possession.

    15:47

    Think possession. Still sticking with it.

    15:50

    Some real be juice stuff going on here.

    15:52

    Don't say that name two more times.

    15:54

    Come on.

    15:55

    You don't want them here.

    15:56

    No.

    15:57

    So search teams, they're created. They comb the area, they bring in the dogs, they bring in the choppers. Volunteers. Guess what.

    16:06

    When you guess, nothing.

    16:09

    Damn good guess.

    16:10

    Nothing. No tracks. Nothing.

    16:11

    No footprints. No signs of a struggle. No clear direction. It's almost like they vanished. Days turn into weeks, weeks turn into months. Weeks that turned into months, then turned into, well, years. And eventually, guess what we got ourselves a cold case. For years. Nothing. No answers. No sightings. No breakthroughs. Just a truck in the woods with a dog and $32,000. I have to imagine. I mean, if that was our dogs, our dog Biggie's eating the goddamn money.

    16:45

    He's eating the door to get out.

    16:46

    He's busting through. He probably ain't making it. He's a little soft. He got bad hip. Got bad hip. And there was a family. Just what it appeared. Disappeared in thin air. And this isn't like it's 1960, 1950 with technology. This is 2009. We have decent technology. Then. You know what I mean? Like to just find nothing. That's pretty wild, abduction. Well, you're changing it now. Abduction, it's not the ghosts.

    17:16

    Maybe.

    17:17

    What do you mean, maybe? I think it might be an alien abduction.

    17:21

    Yeah.

    17:21

    Is that what you're going with?

    17:22

    Yep.

    17:22

    Okay. Could be. This is a small town, big drama.

    17:28

    I've seen some shows.

    17:30

    Thought you're gonna say, I've seen some. I was like, whoa, making a little spicy.

    17:34

    I mean, things are a little weird out this way.

    17:37

    It is a Little weird. Then, Meg. Four years later, 2013, everything changes. Guess what? They find something.

    17:46

    A bank transaction.

    17:47

    Close. They found human remains.

    17:49

    Oh. I mean, same thing.

    17:51

    Less than three miles from where the truck was discovered. Less than three miles. Three sets of skeletal remains. Bobby, Sherilyn, Madison. And just like that, the mystery shifts. Because now they didn't disappear. They died out there. Here's the problem. The remains, they were so badly decomposed that investigators, they couldn't figure out or come to cause a death. But there was no clear trauma because, I mean, you can still kind of figure that out, I would imagine they can. I don't know how to do it. You took some classes. You think you could figure it out?

    18:30

    Probably not. Not that advanced.

    18:32

    There was no definite. Like, hey, here's some evidence of murder. No answers. Even in death, the mystery, still there. It's crazy, right? Three miles away. They were there the whole time.

    18:47

    Where were they?

    18:47

    I mean, maybe not the whole time,

    18:49

    but, I mean, if you go with

    18:51

    my theory, yeah, they were in Neptune.

    18:55

    And then they came back.

    18:57

    What was that again?

    18:58

    Came back.

    18:58

    Gotcha.

    18:59

    Beamed them.

    19:01

    Beam me up, Scotty.

    19:04

    All right, well, either that or the investigators the first time did not do their job.

    19:08

    I mean, he had a lot of volunteers. He had dogs. And go far enough, three miles. I figured they'd come more than that, right?

    19:15

    You would think, but, you know, fair enough.

    19:18

    How about some theories?

    19:19

    Maybe they didn't.

    19:20

    We got some theories. You want to hear them?

    19:21

    Okay.

    19:22

    Because things get a little messy. Because, let's be honest, there's no single explanation that fits everything. So I'm going to give you the theories that I found that investigators and stuff were going with, kind of logical ones. And then we'll throw in another one, maybe for Meg, if it doesn't come up in this theory, okay, Murder, suicide. Maybe Bobby snapped. Maybe the wife snapped. Maybe there was just a lot of pressure. You know what I mean? The. The pain that he was in, being on disability and everything like that maybe just built up and he just said, enough's enough. But then why would you leave the money? Why would you walk in miles into the woods? Why was there no clear evidence, no weapons, no whatever? I mean, there's probably other ways you could do it. Maybe it was arsenic. Can't smell it, but I'm sure there'd be logs of him buying arsenic, right? Theory one. You're not feeling it. I can. I can. I can just look at you.

    20:19

    You're like, nah.

    20:20

    No.

    20:20

    All right, theory, too, then. Maybe they got lost. I mean, that's simple explanation. They went into the woods, just couldn't find their way back. Maybe one of them had to go to the bathroom. So they pull off, they go to the woods. For some reason, the woods were woods, and they couldn't find their way back.

    20:36

    What if they were, like, while they were doing the search, they were still wandering and then eventually circled back because they were disoriented and turned around.

    20:46

    Maybe, but you would think you would hear helicopters, you would hear dogs. You'd hear people yelling.

    20:50

    Footsteps though, right? Like, why are they not seeing footsteps?

    20:53

    They didn't see anything from there. Okay, but again, they had a truck, they had supplies, they had money. People just don't wander three miles and just die together without trying to get help, right?

    21:06

    Was the truck just parked or did

    21:07

    it, like, break down from everything they saw? It was kind of like parked and the doors were locked, but again, everything was in it. Cell phones, everything. So it's not like. I don't know. I don't buy that one. I don't think that they just wander miles, die together, never ask for help. I mean, if anything, say one of them snaps and they just go, look, you're gonna try to run or do something. You would probably find them in different areas, maybe not together. I don't know. That's what the movies would want you to think, right? Theory three, okay? Drug involvement. This is where my brain's been the whole time. There were rumors, there were connections, possibly dangerous people, but no solid evidence, no arrests, nothing concrete. Maybe they were there for some kind of deal. Explains the cash. Doesn't explain bringing the kid, though. Unless maybe their twisted brains thought, hey, if something goes down, they're not going to do anything.

    22:08

    My kids here, I bring the dog. Maybe the same thing. Protection. I don't know the make of the dog. Maisie's giving me some. Some lab vibes. What about you?

    22:18

    I don't know.

    22:19

    Well, then again, not to judge a book by its cover, but I would have to imagine a couple in a very small town named Bobby and Sherilyn. Probably got some kind of pitbull mix.

    22:28

    I would think that if it was this theory, there would have been more of a rush, more of a panic in the footage that they saw them packing and stuff.

    22:39

    What if they're on drugs and they're high and there's just no care in the world.

    22:42

    The kid, too, though.

    22:43

    Well, the kid wasn't really moving. The kid was 6. Kid was probably just sitting there on a tablet or a phone.

    22:49

    In 2009, probably not.

    22:50

    No, probably not.

    22:53

    Mostly back then, like, it was like, Kindles, Game Boy.

    22:57

    Maybe I still had an old Game Boy.

    22:58

    Maybe.

    22:59

    I don't know. That's just where my brain kind of went. Like, maybe you're twisted, you're high, and you're just kind of going through the motions. You're not really thinking rationally. Just zombie, like, you know, that's. Let's go. Theory four. Okay, this is where things maybe were weird. Cher Lynn believed the high, that there was something in the house. She believed there was something dark. She believed something real. Some people believe they went into the woods because they thought they had to. Now, I'm not saying that's what I think happened in a story like this. And Meg's still holding on to that paranormal. Maybe it was it.

    23:34

    I'm leaning more towards this one.

    23:35

    You think so?

    23:36

    Whether it's that or like a mental, like a psychosis thing, you see things, you hear things.

    23:45

    Yeah. Yeah.

    23:46

    Regardless, become controlling.

    23:49

    Could be maybe. Maybe it was something dark. They all just. But why the woods? Why the area? Why the money? Just.

    23:56

    But if they're crazy, like, can we

    23:57

    all agree, though, that nothing about this case feels normal? Should we. Should we ask Luther his thoughts, see if he's got theories?

    24:06

    Sure.

    24:07

    All right. So that's Luther. His. Our Luther. We're getting ready to wrap up the. The true crime case there in Oklahoma that we were talking about with Bobby Sherilyn, their daughter and their dog. We went through the theories. You know, could it have been, you know, like a murder suicide? Could it have potentially been drugs? Could have been paranormal? Could they have got lost? What's your theory? What have you been able to find on the case? And is there anything that we're missing because we're getting ready to hit him with the sweet outro.

    24:38

    Amos and family. Bobby Sherilyn and their daughter disappeared in Oklahoma in 2009. And their remains were found years later with no cause of death. Their truck was left behind with cash inside, leading to various theories including getting lost, murder, suicide, foul play, or even something drug related. While no cause of death was determined, the mystery remains unsolved. And many suspect foul play due to the odd circumstances and positioning of the bodies.

    25:06

    Yeah, okay, cool. We already covered all that. I asked you, what do you think happened, Luther?

    25:15

    All right, since we're putting cards on the table, my gut leans toward foul play. There's too much strange circumstance from the abandoned truck to the money left behind for it to just be accidental. But honestly, this one is a head scratcher that could Keep us guessing forever. Kind of why it's so gripping. What a puzzle, right?

    25:33

    It's a puzzle. So Meg thinks it was paranormal, like they were possessed and they went through it. I'm thinking it was drug related. They were twisted. There was some kind of deal that they were trying to make, and it just went bad and it just went south.

    25:48

    You know, with all the strange behavior they had leading up, it's easy to imagine something shady was involved. If it was paranormal, though. Well, I guess we'll have to wait until ghosts start giving depositions. Either way, your outro is going to have folks arguing long after the episode ends.

    26:03

    That's what we want, right?

    26:06

    Exactly. If you've got people debating theories and scratching their heads afterward, you've nailed the true crime magic. That's what keeps him coming back for more.

    26:15

    All right, that's all we got for you, Luther. Well, you guys can catch him on the Triple T podcast and on all of his socials that don't exist. All right, Meg, what'd you think of Luther? He wasn't. He wasn't feeling your. Wasn't feeling your paranormal, was he?

    26:31

    But I didn't. I'm torn between that and, like, the mental.

    26:35

    Yeah, I think it could be a combo of that for sure.

    26:38

    Which, if it was like a mental thing, that could also make them believe that there's paranormal.

    26:44

    All right, well, here's the question. Family leaves their home, drives into the mountain, leaves behind everything that matters, and they end up dead just a few miles away. No clear cause, no clear motive, no clear answers. So what happened? Did they run from something? Did they believe something was after them? Or did they walk into a situation that they never had a chance of escaping? I say we let them decide. Meg. Maybe they have a different theory that we didn't even think of, that the, you know, the Reddit warriors or something have out there that we didn't. But I'd love to hear it. Would you drop that in the comments? Let's hear your theory. Cuz in a case like this, the truth might not be what actually happened. It might be what people believed happened. That was the your Town podcast. That was a good one. Cool. Good call. I was going a whole different direction, but I'm glad we did some true crime. This one felt better.

    27:37

    This one felt right.

    27:39

    You haven't done one in a while.

    27:40

    Yeah, we're back. All right, that's all we got. You got anything else?

    27:45

    No.

    27:46

    All right, let's go get ready. We got a lot of basketball this weekend. Okay. And then the next, then maybe the next. And sprinkling some softball and some dance. We got some things to do.

    27:58

    Yeah.

    27:59

    All right, everybody. We'll be back next week. Thank you for hanging out with us on the your town podcast. We'll be back next week.

    28:05

    Bye. Bye. Bye.

    28:27

    If you like the show, please take a moment to rate, review and subscribe. It really does help the show to grow. Thank you for listening.

    The Jamison Family Disappeared Leaving Everything Behind | Oklahoma's Strangest Mystery

    0:00
    0:00